A Data Story © 2024 HumAngle Interactive
IPOB’s Monday Curfews Through The Lens Of Google’s Foot Traffic Data
Publication Date: July 15, 2024
Story by Mansir Muhammed
A Data Story © 2024 HumAngle Interactive
Publication Date: July 15, 2024
Story by Mansir Muhammed
We collected open-source data on over 100 locations in southeastern Nigeria, including businesses and public places, which show significantly lower activity on Mondays.
Every weekday, most communities in southeastern Nigeria bustle with life during business hours. Every weekday except Monday, that is, when they become almost unrecognisable due to the closure of businesses and the absence of people in public places.
Groups associated with the Indigenous People of Biafra (IPOB) and Biafra secessionist movements in the region have drawn widespread attention due to their ongoing campaigns for a sovereign state. The various violent wings, like the infamous Autopilot, have been able to get millions of people to comply as they enforce an illegal curfew over specific days — especially Mondays and other days dedicated to the trial of IPOB founder Nnamdi Kanu.
They compel the locals across five southeastern Nigerian states to observe a form of protest against Kanu’s treatment by "sitting at home'', often resorting to violence to ensure compliance.
Geographic contexts like proximity to forest hideouts and remoteness of location from major city centres may be contributing to civilians’ adherence to the enforced curfew. Activity data gathered from the average weekly foot traffic on Google Maps’ popular times between September 2023 and February 2024 would suggest so.
Compliance with the sit-at-home would indicate that the prospect of violence is sufficient motivation for locals across the region.
Among the five affected states, there have been more sit-at-home attacks in Imo (23), followed by Enugu (16). Anambra has also seen armed men who were enforcing sit-at-home orders attack civilians at least 11 times, one more than Ebonyi. Although there are some IPOB-related aggressions in Abia, the data showed three were specifically carried out in response to the sit-at-home order.
ACLED data shows that between September 2018 and March 2024, there have been at least 153 IPOB-related acts of aggression towards civilians and the state. At least 63 of these are related to the enforcement of the sit-at-home order across the South East.
Businesses, establishments and high-activity areas, including bus stations, filling stations, major markets, malls and local stores, restaurants and recreation areas, have recorded a major decline in visitors on Mondays. The same data shows a significant spike in activities from Tuesdays onward.
The red line in this chart represents the average weekday foot traffic for the entire South East region measured against the average individual Monday foot traffic per state.
There are, however, a few exceptional cases.
The traffic data did not record significant changes in some places, including recreational centres, some tertiary transport hubs in Aba, and other establishments near the local government administrative headquarters towns. This is likely due to factors such as security presence, distance from the bushes, history of IPOB presence, and already low visitation rates.
Business owners and operators have cried out over how the sit-at-home order threatens their livelihoods.
“Nobody in Aba will ever sell or buy anything today. The state government is only trying to show the Federal Government that they’re in charge, but IPOB owns the town.”
__ Eke Steven, Aba trader, to Business Day.
"I lose about ₦200,000 every sit-at-home day."
__ Ndu, Anambra resident and trader, to Premium Time.
“I deal in computer accessories, and I know what I normally make on Mondays. But this has stopped suddenly. Customers are being diverted from the zone to other regions of the country. We are indeed losing a lot on Mondays as a people.”
__ Chika Nwogba, businessman in Anambra, to Punch .
As business owners and customers stay home, various establishments have recorded less foot traffic on Mondays. This has had far-reaching impacts on the region’s economy. Last year, the International Center For Investigative Reporting (ICIR) estimated that micro-businesses in the South East lose ₦4.6 trillion ($3.7 billion) annually due to the Monday curfews.
[At first, I did not take the sit-at-home order seriously.] All of a sudden, it started holding, even in December, which is usually our business season.”
__ Emmanuel Ndu, Enugu businessman, to Premium Times.
“There is a need for the drivers to dissociate themselves from the non-existent Monday sit-at-home because such action is negatively affecting the economic activities of the region with drivers in the state at the receiving end.”
__ Moses Nwabueze, President, Urban Drivers Welfare Association of Anambra, to Punch.
"We need full assurance of the security of lives and properties. We want to be in a safe environment. It is not only the government telling us to come out; what are the measures put in place to protect the people anytime there is an attack?”
__ Imo residents to Vanguard .
At the same time, sympathisers believe it is a necessary evil. Some locals have expressed their support for these groups’ actions, even at their own expense.
”I am at home in solidarity to the IPOB, we are not disturbing anybody, we are only making our demands known and we won’t stop until we actualise Biafra”.
__ A trader observing the curfew to Daily Trust.
Local authorities believe that key separatist figures, especially in the diaspora, leverage these platforms to enlist agents. Research conducted last December further supports this, indicating that poverty plays a significant role in motivating individuals to join separatist movements in the region.
Many people justify their support for the separatist groups with what they perceive as systematic marginalisation of the region. Groups like IPOB utilise this sentiment as they advocate for the restoration of the Republic of Biafra, which seceded from Nigeria before rejoining after the Nigerian Civil War in the late 1960s.
The federal government classifies such anti-Nigerian state sentiments as terrorism, designating IPOB as such in 2017 under the Nigerian Terrorism Act. However, a court overturned this classification last year. Nonetheless, the underlying conditions persist, with experts asserting that there is currently no viable pathway for a peaceful resolution to the crisis. The stakes for compromise are deemed too high for either side to come to the negotiating table.
Nnamdi Kanu, whose release is among the demands set by these groups to end the protest curfew, was recently denied bail. Consequently, the government has leaned mainly on kinetic action as its primary approach to addressing the ongoing unrest, leading to a heightened security presence in the region.
Various anti-state groups are present throughout Nigeria, with some evolving or adopting new forms, such as factions of the Oduduwa Republic in the South West. However, the sit-at-home strategy stands out as a distinctive feature of the crisis in the South East. This enforced protest has inflicted significant economic repercussions on the region's inhabitants, yet its effectiveness in eliciting the desired government response remains questionable.
We collected foot traffic data from major cities across Nigeria for comparison. Data from Abuja, Ikeja, Kano City, Maiduguri, and Port Harcourt shows that Monday activities are typically higher compared to other weekdays. However, in the South East, the trend is reversed.
The insurgency in the South East began to gain serious traction in January 2021 when the Nigerian military engaged IPOB’s emerging militant wing, the Eastern Security Network (ESN), in Orlu, Imo state. The situation continued to snowball and then worsened when the government arrested Kanu later in 2021 after an Interpol operation extradited him over anti-state conspiracies and jumping bail. This inspired his supporters to resort to terror tactics to secure his release. Mondays became a sit-at-home day against socioeconomic events across all five southeastern states.
In their enforcement of the order, the groups’ tactics range from raids on market areas, sporadic firing at businesses and people, burning down establishments, and even employing roadblocks to fire at oncoming targets. They sometimes record these violent acts for online publication before retreating to their bases in the bushes, employing the highly evasive tactics used by terrorists in the North West and jihadi extremists in the North East.
“Shoot them, kill them, destroy everything and set it on fire since they cannot obey simple instructions. They were asked to stay at home, but they neglected the instruction.”
__IPOB gunman, in a viral video .
Locals are unable to do business, and the government has been unable to give citizens enough confidence to disregard the curfew instructions. Security forces often face off with the groups when they go on raids and when non-state actors attack them in their police and military posts. This makes the region highly unstable, and Monday activities have become restricted under these circumstances.
“Even if there is an emergency, there is a 50/50 chance anyone won’t get killed before getting to the hospital. Different IPOB militants are doing their thing. Now, they are in fragments. The only way you can get medical attention is if a medical practitioner stays close to your area.”
__Daberechukwu Ajieh from Enugu to HumAngle .